June 9, 2023
Office of the President
One State Farm Plaza
Bloomington, IL 61710
Dear State Farm,
On the evening of May 30, 2023, I called State Farm
to report a comprehensive claim. It was the very first call I made after
my driver side front tire blew, and shredded, while I was coming home
on I-96. I was just beyond the Grand Rapids, Michigan exits, and could
see the sign for exit 46 ahead of me from where I sat at the side of
the road. I called my agent's office (517 627-8600), expecting that
consider the time of day I would be redirected to an after hours number.
I was. I followed all the automated prompts until the nice sounding
female voice told me she was sending a text to my cell phone, and I
needed to tap it. I have a flip phone. It is impossible for me to tap
a text. I thought if I just waited on the line I would surely be redirected
to a real person. Not so, as your automated system just kept telling
me I did not tap the text, so she was resending it. After her fourth
text, I discerned I was never going to get past this dead end. Praise
God, I had an actual State Farms Claims (855 341-8184) number in my
phone, and using that number I was able to eventually reach a real person.
She took my claim, gave me a list of body shops, from which I selected
Gerber in Grand Ledge, and called a wrecker service on my behalf. She
provide me "good neighbor" service. The tow company called me shortly
after we hung up, and let me know they were 55 minutes away. I share
this part of the story only because your CCC MVR shows the "Claim Reported"
date as 06/07/2023 which is clearly false. You might wish to make sure
all of your other records show the claim was reported promptly as Consumer
Cellular records will bear out.
While I was waiting for the tow truck, I took some
pictures, then I called a personal friend, whom I had spoken with earlier
in the day, to tell him how things had taken an unexpected turn. After
hearing about the damage, he cautioned me about State Farm, saying you
would low-ball the value of the vehicle to deem it a total loss, as
you had done to him recently. I assured him that with my having been
a State Farm agent for twenty years, I understood the process, and expected
a true evaluation of the value of my car. Twenty-nine years ago, he
was a policyholder of mine in the days I would explain to a customer
that the market value of a vehicle was what you could realistically
have sold it for one second before the claim occurred. However, as it
turned out, he was quite prophetic, and that is what this letter is
about.
I do not have Internet at home. After 30 years with
Comcast, I got fed up with their games and bullying of customers who
pointed out errors (info at https://wsharing.com/WS-NLE-220307-BC.htm
titled Battling Comcast), refusing
to just accept their perspective as gospel, and I terminated all my
connections with them. I go to a local church to use their
Wi-Fi to upload my picture of the week onto my www.wsharing.com
website. That is also when I check emails (every Thursday). When I checked
my emails on June 1, 2023 I had four
emails from State Farm. The first
two from 5/30/23 basically acknowledge my claim, the one from 5/31/23
says the estimate was done, but it was the email dated 6/1/23 that is
most pertinent to this letter. All of the original emails are saved
as PDF files. In order to keep the file size reasonable for display
on my website, I cropped that PDF message, and saved it as a jpg file.
I wanted you to see exactly how it showed, bold print and all. On the
original, it is clearer that the word repair in the list is also in
bold print.
I thought that message was pretty straight forward.
At home, I printed a copy of it, and took it to the body shop on Friday
for their files to show you had authorized them to begin repairs. I
even saw my friend on Sunday, and told him his concerns had been appreciated,
but unfounded, since State Farm had already approved repairs. Paul Harvey,
a radio broadcaster, used to say, "and now you get the rest of the story."
There is indeed more.
On Wednesday, June 7, 2023 my wife phoned me from
up north to say Miles from State Farm claims was trying to reach me.
I needed to call him back at 855 231-1590 ext 711. The automated phone
system did not seem to offer me a prompt for an extension, so I simply
put in 711 after it answered. A young woman answered. When I told her
I was trying to reach Miles at extension 711, she said it was what I
had reached, and she could help me. I called where a pencil and paper
were not handy, so I do not know her name. As she explained that the
car was being declared a total, I said I had an email that had already
authorized repairs. I talked about the unusual value of the car. But,
because I had mentioned it had been my dad's, she started most of her
rhetoric with "I understand the car has sentimental value to you." I
kept interrupting her, because apparently she thought I was stupid,
even after I told her I had been a State Farm agent for twenty years,
and already understood the process they used to determine their position.
I did not say it, but I had to explain years ago to my policyholders,
that market value was not impacted by any sentimental attachment to
their vehicle. She did not like my interruptions, and I did not like
her wasting my time telling me things I already knew, so I asked to
be transferred to a supervisor. She said one would call me back.
Around noon, Monique (claims supervisor) called me.
Her dog was barking in the background, so it was clear that she was
working from home, wherever home might be. I knew I had already talked
with Texas, and Colorado, because I simply asked. She was not as condescending
as her underling, but it was easy to realize from the start she was
going to be protective of the person under her, and I would be wasting
my time with her, as well. After she started to tell me what I already
knew, and I interrupted her to say just that, I finally said I would
be challenging your determination, and to start whatever process was
necessary. She said she would send me the market value report (CCC MVR
mentioned earlier) by email, and did give me one piece of information
I was not familiar with. She said that, in Michigan, a car could be
declared a total loss if the cost to repair it was 75%, or higher, of
the stated market value. She also told me that the email I received
the previous week authorizing repairs was irrelevant because it was
generated by your computers. Nobody I have showed the email to since
our conversation has thought that hers was a legitimate excuse. Most
remarked, then they should not be letting their computer send out such
an email in the first place.
I tried to call the body shop to alert them State
Farm was changing their tune. No one answered, and I declined to stay
on the line for redirection to a national call center. My wife had already
informed them that I would be fixing the car regardless, when she picked
up a copy of the estimate the previous week. They told her then if State
Farm declared it a total they would not do the work. I completely understand
why, and that was not a problem at the time.
On Thursday afternoon (6/8/23), I uploaded my picture
of the week, and checked emails. Two had arrived from State Farm. They
were both sent 6/7/23. Each had an attachment. One was the vehicle evaluation,
and another State Farm claims telephone number. The other said "Please
open the attachment(s) for more claim information or next steps." Beyond
my basic responsibilities, I am the primary volunteer for two struggling
small non-profits that grew out of my mission activities this past 29
years. My time is usually jammed with stuff waiting for my attention.
So, I simply saved them all to my USB drive as PDF documents, to look
at later. Plus, I do not have time to listen to people trying to justify
something that is simply not true, so I knew I would not be calling
anyone.
That evening, at home, I opened the PDF files. The
one that stating it had claims info said this:
So, on Friday (6/9/23) I took a copy of the email
over to the body shop. They looked at one another, then said, we are
not charging storage fees on your claim. I asked if they would be willing
to put the spare tire on so I could drive it home, since I did not know
how long this battle with State Farm was going to take. They did not
have a tech person to do that until Monday, so I asked if they thought
I could get it to my house with the remaining rubber on the wheel, considering
their estimate indicated the wheel was already damaged. Aaron said we
should go out in the yard, and take a look. Upon inspection, Aaron said
he would not chance it if it were his car, and explained why. I suggested
we should check to be sure there actually was a spare. Aaron helped
me move stuff from the trunk to the back seat, and there is indeed one
they can put on the car Monday. In the course of conversation, Aaron
said he understood why I was insisting I would fix the car, because
he could see it was in really good condition. I shared with him that
the 20 year old driver of the tow truck, on the drive back to Grand
Ledge, had told me that when he saw the great condition, and how clean
the underside was, he put on a special bracket so his chains and hooks
would not scrape up, or potentially damage the car in any way. Aaron
indicated that was very thoughtful of the young man. Aaron also offered
he could put in writing, and sign, a document stating I would not be
charged any storage fees relating to this claim. (online see
addendum) Your email, in
all honesty, felt more like a tactic to rush a policyholder into accepting
your determination. After discovering that the email was also a lie
with regards to storage charges, it looked more like big corporation
bullying.
The market valuation report was fifteen pages long.
No doubt, it was supposed to impress me with how thorough it was by
its sheer length. It did not. Every one of the ten categories deemed
my car to be "average private." I will include some pictures later that
will refute that. But first let us look at the most basic aspect of
the report.
If you take $3,797 and multiply it by .75, the result
is $2,847.75, a figure $38.66 above your body shop estimate of $2,809.09
which is only 74% (in fact slightly less than that) of your determined
value of my car. No one ever told me you could randomly ignore the percentage,
and decide a lower one is close enough if it suits your fancy. I am
sending a copy of this to the Michigan Attorney General Consumer Complaints
department, and the Michigan Department of Insurance, because if you
can legally do this, it is simply wrong, and Michigan needs better laws
to protect against such random abuse of its citizens. If an independent
appraiser, which I know I may get at my own expense and time, were to
find the value of my car was closer (which is quite likely) to the list
price of $5000 on your "comparable vehicle number two," which had 20,000
more miles than my car has, what then? That would put my vehicle repairs
at 56% of the market value. Do you get to declare 56% close enough to
call it a total loss because you feel like it?
This vehicle spent 21 years in Florida, with just
one owner. I am 72 years old. Anyone with common sense knows that in
Michigan, those two factors alone would increase the market price above
any average car. But, just in case you still insist on ignoring the
truth, here is a picture of the engine I took when my wife brought the
car back to Michigan. I actually took fourteen pictures (see online
addendum for additional photos)
on May 21, 2021 because when the mechanic (now deceased) who took care
of our cars happened to drop by our house, and I showed him the engine
of our new car, he declared, oh my goodness, I have never seen an engine
that clean, especially in a 21 year old vehicle. A year ago, even a
dealer, who happened to be pumping gas at the same time I was, came
over to my car and asked if I would be interested in selling it because
he had never seen a 2000 Impala in such exceptional condition. He was
not the first to ask, nor the last.
Here is the last picture taken of the car. It was
shot 5/30/23 two hours before the claim.
After my experience with
Comcast, I am composing this letter
as a webpage, and will be loading it along with other comments, and
documentation, to my website on Thursday. I spent way too much money
on printing and mailing costs doing battle with them. When I read the
opening email to my wife, her comment was that she thinks it would be
blatantly clear to a court of law. But, Scripture tells me to try to
settle things without going to court, so I do not file lawsuits. I also
do not have the time, nor care to spend the money, to prove your fancy
market value report wrong. I will seek a simpler solution.
We do have a problem here though, because apparently
this is not the same State Farm of integrity that I became an agent
for almost half a century ago. If it were, you would have stood behind
your first email (above), and no other communication would have been
necessary. Because of that sentimental value your claims person kept
trying to focus on, I will be fixing my car, but not just because it
belonged to my dad. I have first hand knowledge of how meticulous my
dad was about taking care of his cars. Your modern fancy system filled
with pages of digital documentation cannot begin to truly calculate
an accurate value in such a circumstance. A local good neighbor agent
(or adjuster) could have told you in a flash this was an unusual situation.
Any of my real neighbors who have seen the car could tell you the car
we brought up from Florida is in exceptional condition. You would be
hard pressed to find any car this age in a Michigan dealers lot in as
clean, and in good shape, as this one, even at their high prices. You
are simply in the wrong. The bigger problem is I no longer trust you.
I will not communicate with you by phone because it leaves me no written
documentation. I will still communicate with you through my local agent
Cheri Locker, since her office shows the desire, and understanding,
of this plaque from my State Farm days, that I still keep hung on the
walls of the Teaching & Sharing Center of Grand Ledge because of its
universal message, and wisdom.
Your claims person wanted to waste my time
telling me about your buyback program. I am already familiar with it.
You cannot sell back to me something I already own. Unless you are planning
on stealing it by manipulating numbers, or ignoring guidelines as it
suits your fancy, it is still mine, and I am not agreeing to anything
which puts it into your hands, not even for a moment. I have been a
policyholder for almost fifty years, and always carried no deductible
comprehensive on my vehicles, even when they got older. I would have
preferred to have paid all of those premiums and never had a claim using
it. But, stuff happens. The only thing at this point which will prolong
this battle, is if you continue to maintain your false claim that this
qualifies as a total. That would preclude me from carrying comprehensive
(and paying the premiums) on something I have deemed so important for
so many years. By the time you get this letter, I will likely have my
vehicle at my home. You will need to put something in actual writing,
not another email you can claim was simply sent by your computer system,
if you wish adjust your stand on my claim. Honestly, the only thing
I see left to be determined is how much you believe you fairly owe toward
the repair of a car under the terms of the policy for a claim submitted
to you by a longtime loyal policyholder. Not a penny more. Not a dollar
less. When you figure that out, you could simply send me a check. If
I deem it to be reasonable, I will get my car repaired without any more
involvement from State Farm. If I should deem it to be unreasonable,
I will still get my car repaired without any more involvement from State
Farm. But, in that case, by this time next year, State Farm will not
be receiving any premium dollars from me for anything. If you wish to
communicate with me other than in writing, you may do so through Cheri
Locker, my local good neighbor agent.
It is striking to me that most of the people
whom I have encountered through this incident have treated me like a
good neighbor, except for those who advertise the concept.
|
Respectfully,
|
|
(printed copy was signed by me)
|
|
William Gibbons Jr
(claim #22-50N1-78B)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
cc:
|
Attorney General
Consumer Complaints
G. Mennen Williams Bldg
P O Box 30212
Lansing, MI 48909
|
|
Department of Insurance
530 West Allegan
Lansing, MI 48837
|
|
Cheri Locker State Farm Office
450 E Saginaw Hwy Suite 101
Grand Ledge, MI 48837
|
_____________
The State Farm total loss department called
my phone on Monday, June 12, at 1:49 pm. I declined to answer it. So,
a woman named Sue left a voicemail. Then someone, I presume it was Sue,
called my wife. She answered, then kept asking me how to reply to what
Sue was saying to her. It was clear that Sue was pressuring her by mentioning
she had spoken with Kris (general manager) at Gerber Body Shop. Finally
my wife got so frustrated with what Sue was saying, she put her phone
on its speaker. I walked over to the phone, and told whoever it was
[likely Sue], we were tired of the lies we were getting from the State
Farm claims department. I had a written signed document from Gerber
stating I would not be charged any storage fees. I had already written
a letter to corporate, sent a copy of it to the Michigan Attorney General,
and the Michigan Department of Insurance. Told her, I was not going
to speak with claims anymore because of their lies, and that this conversation
was ended. I was less than cordial. Which, as a domestic missionary,
is a line I never like to cross. But, by that time they had pushed me
enough, I could scarcely believe I was speaking with the same company
I had been an agent for (1975-1994).
Later that afternoon we went to the body
shop to pick up my car. On the way, I went into Cheri Locker's office
(my local State Farm agent), and dropped off a copy of the corporate
letter. Aaron admitted he had forgotten, but found someone, and helped
them put on my spare, and they zip tied up the lower front panel so
it would not drag on the ground. When I brought up Sue's call, I was
told it was State Farm who insisted all their claims would be charged
no storage fees. Aaron had previously told me it was their policy to
help however they could. I am not sure if he was speaking of the local
body shop, or the Gerber corporation nationally, but here in Grand Ledge
they have completely treated me with good neighbor service. I am very
grateful to them for both their help, and their honesty.
_____________
On Wednesday, June 14, 2023 I got a call from my
agent, Cheri Locker. She had been out of town, and this was her first
day back in the office since I dropped off a copy of my letter to corporate.
She had reviewed it, and was asking questions electronically with a
longtime State Farm employee in the claims department as we spoke. I
will not get into all of the details of the conversation, but she said
it looks like much of the problem has been a communications issue, and
assured me that she believes no one at State Farm would intentionally
lie to us. I told her the car is mine, and I would not be surrendering
the title, not even for a second. She asked Jake (not the TV Jake),
if any settlement would require me to bring in the title, and he said
no. I told her to have State Farm put in writing how they are offering
to settle the claim, and I will get it from her office, then give them
my reply back through her office.
Cheri closed with the following statement. "We have
been friends a long time. I assure you State Farm has not changed, or
I would have already retired. Systems have changed, and the challenges
have changed. But, our core values have not changed. I have not lost
my faith in the core values."
_____________
_____________
On June 16, 2023 at 7:30 a.m. my wife received a
text message on her phone saying State Farm had paid the towing bill.
I presume that was paid under our road service coverage.* When I was
an agent, the road service limit was based on "the amount it would have
cost to have the car towed to the nearest facility where repairs could
reasonably be expected to be made." When I first called in my claim
from the road, the claims person gave me three options for body shops,
all
between Grand Ledge and Portland. I told her Grand Ledge would seem
the logical choice since it was not even two miles from where I live.
She never hesitated. She said she would immediately call to have
my car towed to the Grand Ledge shop. That tow bill was over $400. That
was truly Good Neighbor service. It is important for people to know
State Farm had their moments where the light shined through.
* When I saw the actual check, it was paid under
comprehensive coverage, not road service.
_____________
On June 19, 2023 my State Farm agent called to see where I was in my
thought process regarding the claim. We spoke for a lengthy time going
over various points, but if I am not in a spot where I can immediately
write down the main points of a verbal conversation, I prefer not to
reconstruct it later on. Nonetheless, as I pondered what she said, I
wrote the below letter which I delivered to her office June 20,
2023 to be forwarded to the appropriate people.
June 20, 2023
Claim Number 22-50N1-78B
Dear State Farm,
It appears we will simply need to agree to disagree. Neither of us
has the time, nor the inclination, to prove the other wrong. You think
you are right about the value of my car, and the total loss determination,
because you have (or someone has) a computer that spits out 15 page
reports about car values. I think I am right because I have over half
a century of practical experience, including 20 years as a State Farm
agent, working directly with State Farm field adjusters, who taught
me what pertains, and what does not, when determining the value of a
vehicle.
If I were to turn out right, you are overpaying the claim. I do not
believe it will cost me that much to repair my car. However, as my State
Farm agent has amply explained, from your perspective, you are paying
exactly what you owe because you still maintain the car qualifies as
a total loss.
I will not sign anything that would even imply that I agree with
your assessment the car is a total. Nor, will I ever refer to such a
thing as “buying back” my car. As I have clearly explained, you cannot
sell back to me something I already own. I have already been promised
by State Farm claims, through my agent, you will not attempt to impugn
my title in any way.
Whether or not you choose to let me keep comprehensive coverage is
up to you. Repairs are already underway, and I would be surprised if
I would have any trouble finding a company who will let me pay them
extra premium dollars to have comprehensive coverage on a car in such
good shape. After having four new tires put on the car (4/19/23), I
drove it directly to my State Farm agent’s office to let them see firsthand
what I have been talking about. I suspect it is likely the first time
anyone fully connected with State Farm has ever seen my car.
Beyond the value issue, I still think your system is broken. Relying
on automated electronic communications that are later retracted, or
turn out to be completely false, does not put you in the best light.
Out of a relatively small circle of family and friends that I have spoken
with, two different people recently had similar experiences with State
Farm. One is already looking for a different insurance company. The
other, a friend I had as a policyholder when I was an agent, is still
with you, but pretty disgruntled. Yet, it is not my place to tell you
how to run your business.
So, if we can agree to disagree, just issue your payment, and we
will be done with this matter. I have provided my agent with a voided
check along with this letter, so she may provide you with my credit
union routing information.
God’s peace, |
(printed copy was signed by me) |
william |
William Edward Gibbons Jr
419 South Bridge Street
Grand Ledge, MI 48837
_____________
CLOSING THOUGHTS
_____________
Challenging big corporations when you think they are wrong can be
a daunting task. Documentation is a key component. Always speaking the
truth, and not trying to twist the truth to your advantage is also essential.
Once you know there is an issue, you need to stop talking with them
on the phone, because (unless you are recording the conversation) you
are left with no documentation of what was said, or promises made. You
need to make it clear that communications with you need to be in a written
form you can save. You need to be willing to involve government agencies,
or elected officials, if needed, and provide them with factual documentation.
You especially need to get your information into the hands of someone
with authority in the corporation. Front line people seldom have authority.
It is okay to say how you feel about something, but do not confuse feelings
with facts. Finally, when you have done everything you can, you need
to be willing to leave outcomes in God's hands. And, of course, if you
were really treated badly, do not continue doing business with them,
if possible. The Peace Pilgrim materials I use give some pretty good
advise about resolving conflicts. Of course, her basic message is good
across the board.
Overcome evil with good, falsehood with truth, and hatred with love.
I do not like it when I am less than civil to someone.
Yet keeping your cool
can be difficult when you are in the midst
of conflict. Still, it is good to remember that all negativity on our
part, like anger, hate,
or
retaliation, will harm us
more
emotionally, mentally, spiritually, and even physically, than others.
We live in impersonal corporate times where technology, speed, and efficiency
have replaced relationship. Service has been replaced with putting the
burden onto the consumer. Frustration and anger can become just natural
byproducts if we let them. My only real solution is focusing on God.
Keeping God in the center of what I do. Turning back to Him if I get
sidetracked.
_____________
As a domestic missionary who promotes using the question
"what would Jesus have me do?" in all decisions Christians face, I must
take His advice in Scripture seriously. Yet forgiveness clashes with
one of my favorite admonition sayings, "fool me once, shame on you,
fool me twice, shame on me." As I look back on this journey, I am reminded
of a State Farm automated phone system that takes people to a dead end
if they do not have a smart phone. And, that in an unrelated claim,
it took my wife fifty-five minutes on her phone before she could reach
a real person. In my day everything started at the local office, but
things change. I do not like that I have to deal with people in Texas,
and Colorado, or wherever else, just referred to as "claim team" who
have no real knowledge of me, or my property they are making decisions
about. I remember I tried to explain to Monique the true exceptional
condition of my car by comparing it to those you might see in a classic
car show. She sarcastically remarked I do not own a classic car. No,
I do not, but I have photographed hundreds of cars at many shows, and
the above photo bears out my claim. I remember how it felt when she
was justifying their decision, and telling me their email
a week earlier which had said I should begin repairs was irrelevant
to the circumstance because it was an automated email sent out by their
computer system. Why send it at all if you are not going to stand by
it. Then the fact that the repair estimate was below the threshold they
should have been using to determine a total. They blew that one off
by saying there could be more damage. Yes, that is possible. But, it
is also possible there is no additional damage underneath. Especially
since I was able to bring my car to a rolling stop with what rubber
was still on the wheel. Once they declared my car to be a total loss,
nobody was going to look. It is all supposition still. But, it made
my life more complicated, because the place they had it towed to would
no longer repair it. Right from the start, I have told everybody I would
be fixing the car regardless of what State Farm does, because of its
exceptional condition. Instead of working with me to determine the truth,
State Farm just dumped me into their system, then took the path of trying
to justify their position without all of the facts. Add to that the
lie about storage charges, made more than once. Everything can be explained
away piece by piece, but as a whole it is pretty sloppy work for a corporation
that has remained among the top of the "good guys" list consistently
throughout its history. It was frustrating, and disappointing, to experience
this process, but even more so to hear the excuses. Years ago, an advertising
agency person was sent by State Farm to interview me as a possible candidate
for one of the real agent commercials State Farm used before TV Jake.
One of the questions the interviewer asked was why I chose insurance?
I said I did not choose insurance. I came to a job interview, and was
so impressed with State Farm as a company, I chose State Farm. It just
happened to be they were only in the insurance business. We did not
always see eye to eye, but when I left them for the path I felt God
was calling me to, I still believed they deserved to be among the top
on that "good guys" corporations list. Even now, if State Farm can find
a comp three car in the same exceptional condition as the car I own,
and could actually buy it in today's economy for the value they have
placed on my car, I would relent, and say they are right, I am wrong.
But, that is not going to happen. No insurance company has that kind
of time, or the inclination. They just play with the numbers, which
may, or might not, reflect the real world, or the truth. Plus, such
a comp car might not even exist. But, my car does exist. And, I can
prove with photographs, and the undamaged rest of the car itself, that
when I use the words unique situation, and exceptional condition, my
position is closer to the truth, than State Farm's. But, even if they
sent someone once to look over the vehicle, they cannot know that from
Texas, Colorado, or who knows where else, for a car now parked back
in my driveway in Grand Ledge, Michigan. And, just because their numbers
come from a computer program, does not mean they reflect reality.
_____________
After my conversation with Cheri, I was trying to
give State Farm the benefit of the doubt. On my cardiac walk, I stopped
in at a non-profit arts place I have been a part of for a long time.
In the course of conversation it turns out the woman behind the desk
went through almost the very same experiences with State Farm recently,
including the whole "storage charges" thing while her car was at Gerber.
She pushed the issue, and when the State Farm claims person checked
into it, they came back and said, you are right. Gerber does not charge
us storage fees. So, are we, the mass of State Farm policyholders (who
by the way are the owners in a mutual company) supposed to feel better
because such things stem from ignorance, or incompetence, instead of
intentional? It does not inspire confidence. In fact, the lady I was
speaking with has already begun arrangements to move her insurance to
another company. When I mentioned to Cheri the remark from the fellow
now doing the body work about not being able to find a decent used car
for less than five or six thousand dollars, she misinterpreted it as
my claiming that to be my car's value. I explained to her I do not wish
to take advantage of State Farm, just like I do not want them
to take advantage of me. I just want my car fixed. I could not even
do that at Gerber once State Farm declared it to be a total. "Fool me
once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me," or forgiveness? It
is a really good question.
_____________
The founder of State Farm did so because he thought
the insurance companies of his day were treating him unfairly. They
told him if he did not like it, then go start your own insurance company.
He did. Historically, it has been a great company. In these highly competitive
times, with new alternatives arriving regularly, consumers have more
power than they realize to stand up to businesses they believe are mistreating
them, including the big corporations. Even State Farm. The penny and
dollar reference in the closing of my letter to State Farm comes from
my days as an agent of theirs. We were told the State Farm philosophy
was to pay every dollar we owed under the terms of our policies. Not
a penny more. But not a dollar less.
This letter is now a part of my Newsletters, Letters,
& Emails archives. It will remain here in perpetuity. If someday
it should help another State Farm customer find relief, or even restitution,
for wrongs they perceive are being perpetrated against them, that would
not hurt my feelings at all. State Farm has a strong foundation of doing
right. If they happen to forget that, maybe a little nudge will help
them to remember those words of Adlai H. Rust. He was one one of the
earlier presidents of the company, before my time with them, but I still
display his words of wisdom.
_____________
With all the demands on my time, one might wonder why I would spend
so much of it doing this? The last line in the Cherokee Bill's Teaching
& Trade Center Mission Statement reads, "To heighten awareness of
historical and present injustice and prejudice." I do not see State
Farm as a company who shows prejudice. And the word injustice might
be a bit strong, but if I get the impression that a big corporation
is trying to run rough shod over me, I see it as fitting in as a part
of my mission.
I originally dreaded having to find the time to write
to State Farm stating I was challenging that my car is a total loss.
Then, I woke up one morning seeing it as a teaching and sharing opportunity
if I did it as a webpage. It went from dread, to making
it a top priority of my mission, something God would have me do. Putting
God in the center changes how I perceive
anything.
FINAL THOUGHTS
This is not the same as the
Comcast situation. There, I could
decide to simply do without cable TV, and the Internet connected to
my house. I have found, that while sometimes inconvenient, my life is
actually better without either of those. In this case, I am required
to carry insurance on any vehicle I own that is driven on public roads.
Therefore, the main decision I have yet to make, is do I believe State
Farm still provides this service better than, or at least as good as,
any other
company in the insurance business I could go with. At this point,
it is not as easy a question to answer as it would have been before
my claim experience.
Hard as it might be for some people to understand,
this has never been about money. It has always been about the truth.
I have believed now for many decades that the paramount goal in life
is to learn, and live, the Truth. That journey can also be a daunting
one.
_____________